Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Shortening AdvisorDude's grant

It frightens me that when reading AdvisorDude's RO1 revision in order to shorten it by 7 lines, and noticing that 2 sub-aims in the grant basically test the same freakin' question and subsequent alarm bells going off in my head, that a phone call to AdvisorDude's office yields this response "Ehh, I don't care anymore, I am NOT changing anything. They wanted a more mechanistic Sub Aim, that is what they are getting. Just shorten the grant..."

I understand that he is sick of it at this point. But changing the Aims so that it is more clear that one method gets at one part of the question, while another method gets at another part of the question, would have sufficed. I had to think about what he was getting at in the grant (too much). I was always taught that if your reviewer has to think, then you are in trouble.

I'm not sure if this always holds true. But I would more likely lower his score (in the bad way) if too many alarms go off in my head or if I have to question things. I really wish he would have been a little bit more open about this.

No comments:

Post a Comment